India's New Zealand tour is less about trophies, more about answers, says K R Nayar
A Rediff column argues that India's real win in New Zealand would be coming home knowing what kind of team it actually wants.

India heads to New Zealand with a squad in flux, and columnist K R Nayar says that is the whole point. In his Rediff piece, he argues the tour's real payoff is not a perfect scorecard but a clear picture of the team India should build next.
There is plenty to sort out. New players have been tried, combinations have been shuffled, and the tour comes with a split captaincy. When head coach Gautam Gambhir has been resting or unavailable, V V S Laxman has stepped into the role, which has fuelled chatter about split coaches as well. A new selection committee, with Pragyan Ojha as chairperson and Ramesh Powar as a new member, has just taken charge.
The West Indies series did little to calm nerves. It was meant to be a stroll, yet India won the ODIs only 2-1 and the T20Is finished level at 2-2. Nayar's question is blunt: India has loads of good cricketers, but does it have enough match-winners, the kind who deliver when a game hangs by a thread?
His diagnosis starts with abundance. Domestic cricket, India A tours, age-group circuits, state teams and the IPL have created many routes to the national side. That is great for depth. It may also be quietly messing with heads. Nayar says competition sharpens players, but insecurity can slip in alongside it. A batter who fears one failure could cost him his spot may play to survive rather than to win. A bowler worried about a pricey spell may stop hunting wickets and start hiding.
Then there is the question of who runs the show. Nayar suggests the captain is not the face and voice of the team, and that the coach holds heavy sway over selection and tactics. That includes workload management, batting order, bowling plans and even field placements. In that setup, he writes, the captain risks becoming an executor rather than a leader.
His advice to selectors is a kind of tough love: know when to change and when to resist the itch. India's depth lets it try different combinations, a luxury many sides lack, but experimentation "has an expiry date", as he puts it. Against a strong opponent, he says, the tour should show whether India's bench strength is real or only looks good on paper, and who the genuine match-winners are.
Read the original column on Rediff: India's New Zealand Tour: A Mirror To Indian Cricket.